Chapter 6 - FIVE MINUTES AT THE LUCKY STAR
The Lucky Star had never looked so much like a fortress. Its front windows were dark except for the occasional flash of movement behind a curtain. Sheriff Holt had slipped inside with Vane, and two hired gunmen covered the rear alley. Townspeople crowded behind wagons and water troughs, armed with rifles that shook in hands unused to choosing sides. Caleb crouched in the dirt with the federal survey tucked beneath his coat. Mama stood beside him pale from months in captivity, one hand pressed to her ribs. I could hear June crying somewhere inside the saloon. Every sound scraped across my nerves. “Five minutes!” Vane shouted again. “Then the little one pays for everybody's courage.” The clock above the mercantile struck three.
Caleb knelt in front of me. “Lily, you stay with your mother.” “No.” “This isn't the mine.” “June is my sister.” “And I'm bringing her out.” “He'll expect you.” Caleb opened his mouth, then stopped because he recognized the look on my face. “What are you thinking?” I pointed toward the alley. When June and I searched for food behind the Lucky Star, we sometimes climbed a woodpile to reach a storeroom window the cook left open for air. Behind flour barrels was a narrow gap where June once hid from a dog. Mae stared at me. “Absolutely not.” “June knows the hiding place.” Caleb studied the roofline. “Show me.” Mama caught my shoulders. “I lost you once already.” “You didn't lose us,” I said. “They took you.” Her eyes filled. “That distinction doesn't make a mother sleep better.”
We moved through the alley while ranchers kept Vane talking from the street. Mae deliberately shouted insults about his parentage to keep attention forward. Caleb climbed the woodpile first, then lifted me through the storeroom window. The room smelled of flour, onions, spilled whiskey, and old wood. “You stay behind me,” he whispered. “For once in your life.” “I'm four.” “That isn't an excuse.” “It's a pretty good one.” Even then, the corner of his mouth moved. We slipped past stacked crates toward the pantry. Through a crack in the door I saw June sitting on the bar. Vane held her against his side, his pistol pressed below her ribs. Holt stood near the front door with another revolver. June's face was wet, but her chin was high.
“Your sister caused a great deal of trouble,” Vane said to her. June sniffed. “Lily causes most trouble.” I almost laughed aloud. Vane tightened his arm around her. “Rourke!” he shouted. “Time!” Caleb leaned close to my ear. “I need him looking away from this door.” “I can do that.” “Lily, no.” Before he could grab me, I stepped into the saloon. The room seemed enormous from the floor. Chairs lay overturned. Glass glittered underfoot. Three guns swung toward me. June's eyes widened. “Lily, you're not supposed to be here.” “Neither are you.” Vane gave a soft laugh. “The brave twin.” “No,” I said. “I'm the angry one.”
“Where's Rourke?” he asked. “Gone.” “Liar.” “You said children lie.” I moved closer to a card table. Holt raised his pistol. “Stay where you are.” I stopped and looked at him. “Papa said you were afraid of Mr. Vane.” Holt's face reddened. Vane glanced toward him. “What did she say?” “Nothing.” “Papa said bad men follow stronger bad men because being alone makes them remember they're cowards.” Holt took a step toward me. “Your father begged before he died.” The room seemed to lose air. Pain hit me so hard I nearly folded. Then I heard Mama's voice in memory: Protect June. I forced my chin up. “Then why did you need three men to kill him?”
Vane snapped, “Shut up, Holt.” Too late. The front windows were open. People outside heard every word. Holt realized it and panicked. “She's twisting things!” I stared at him. “I'm four. You're losing an argument to a four-year-old.” June giggled despite the gun against her. Vane's control cracked. He dragged June tighter and looked toward the street. That was all Caleb needed. He stepped from behind the pantry door. Holt saw him first. “Rourke!” Gunfire exploded. I dropped under the card table. June bit Vane's hand so hard he screamed. She rolled behind the bar. Caleb shot Holt's pistol from his hand, and the weapon spun across the floor.
One hired gunman fired from the stairs. Mae answered from the kitchen with a shotgun blast into the ceiling above him, showering plaster and terrifying him into dropping flat. “Next one's lower!” she shouted. I crawled toward June, but Vane seized the back of my dress and lifted me. His pistol pressed beneath my chin. Every gun in the room stopped. Caleb stood ten feet away, revolver aimed. “Drop it,” Vane ordered. Caleb's jaw clenched. “Now.” Caleb slowly lowered his gun to the floor. Vane smiled. “All this over two unwanted children.” Caleb looked at me, then at June crouched behind the bar. “They were never unwanted.”
Vane laughed. “You lost your wife. You think saving them fixes that?” Something changed in Caleb's face. For the first time since I met him, he stopped using anger to hide sorrow. “No,” he said. “Nothing fixes it.” Vane frowned. Caleb's voice stayed steady. “Eliza is still dead. Elias Bell is still dead. Clara lost months she can never recover. These girls went hungry while a whole town looked away. Grief isn't a debt you pay off by doing one good thing. It doesn't disappear because somebody calls you a hero.” His eyes filled. “But what happens after loss is still ours to choose.” Vane pressed the gun harder into my skin. “Touching.” Caleb looked directly at me. “Lily, close your eyes.”
I did not. Behind Vane, Mama stepped from the hallway holding Mae's cast-iron skillet with both hands. She struck him across the back of the head. The pistol fired into the ceiling. I dropped. Caleb caught me before my face hit the floor. Vane collapsed against the bar. Mama stood over him shaking with rage. Mae entered through the pantry, looked at the bent skillet, and said, “That was my good one.” June crawled from behind the bar laughing and crying at once. Holt lunged for his fallen weapon, but the front doors burst inward. Twenty townspeople poured inside before he reached it. The widow whose husband appeared in the ledger kicked the pistol away. “Not this time,” she said.
Outside, the standoff dissolved into something Mercy Creek had never experienced: accountability. Vane, Holt, Boone, and the hired men were tied to hitching rails under guard. No one cheered. The victory felt too raw for celebration. Mama sat on the boardwalk with June in one arm and me in the other. Caleb leaned against a porch post while Mae wrapped his shoulder. I saw his hands trembling now that there was no one left to shoot. “You all right?” I asked. “No,” he said. “You?” “No.” June wiped her face. “Me neither.” Mama pulled us closer. “Good. We can stop pretending for a while.”
May you like
Near sundown, dust appeared on the eastern road. Six mounted officers rode into town behind a boy whose horse looked ready to fall apart. Ezra Pike slid from the saddle, staggered three steps, and announced, “History owes me two horses.” Mae laughed so hard she cried and hugged him until his boots left the ground. Behind him rode United States Deputy Marshal Nathan Harwood, a lean man with gray at his temples and the tired posture of someone who had seen corruption before. He read the ledger, inspected Papa's survey, listened to Mama's account, and ordered Vane and Holt formally arrested. “This goes to territorial court,” he said.
“Will they get away?” I asked. Harwood looked down at me. Adults often softened their voices around children when they intended to lie. He did not. “They have money, friends, and years of practice bending people,” he said. “So I won't promise easy.” He looked at the crowd, then at the ledger. “But if the truth stays louder than the money, they won't walk away.” Across the street, the Lucky Star sign creaked in the evening wind. For years its painted star had watched Mercy Creek pretend nothing was wrong. Now Vane stood beneath it in irons. Yet as Marshal Harwood turned the ledger's pages, his expression darkened. He stopped at one name near the back. “Judge Horace Mercer,” he said. “Where is he?” Nobody answered. Then Mae swore. The territorial judge who had signed half the disputed deeds had vanished from town that afternoon.
